Powered by Blogger.

Gentle Night Weaning: Finding our own way

I thought, like many mums of breastfeeding toddlers, that it would be totally impossible to night wean my two year old. Any time I read someone's explanation of how they did it, I was hit with a dozen 'but that wouldn't work for us'es. My boy's temparement was different, our sleeping situation was different, his relationship with his daddy was different, his and my breastfeeding relationship was different.

My boy was 2 years 4 months. I decided to tackle night weaning after months of awful aversion, figuring that I might feel totally fine with continuing until he chose to wean, if I could find a way to place that limit on it.
Feeding to sleep, three days into night weaning
I knew that I had done a great job, that we had gone above and beyond all imaginable lengths to be able to have a breastfeeding relationship in the first place, and that being in the situation where I was breastfeeding a two year old was unfathomable -- I was not even sure I'd be able to breastfeed him even once. So to now actively choose to reduce and to limit his breastfeeding, when I had spent the first year of his life doing everything in my power for him to find comfort at my breast, felt awful. I kept getting flashes of the things we had been through... and now I somehow found myself wanting him to stop. 

But this is my body. It was my choice.

Everything I read discussed your toddler being in a separate room from you. He did have his own room, but we had a double bed in there that I would move into after his first wake in the night, and then just attempt to doze and sleep where I could. That was the way of survival.

We did it just fine, still sleeping next to each other from the moment of his first wake, still snuggling, me continuing to be there and comfort him in the night.

Everything I read said to get your partner on board. But any time my husband even entered the room in the evenings, my boy would become completely hysterical.

I decided I needed to do this on my own. I thought this would be the easier way, and I was right.

Everything I read discussed the fact that a certain amount of crying was inevitable, and I have come to learn that I am extremely sensitive to this and his distress -- especially when in relation to me refusing to breastfeed -- felt as if it would cause me just way too much distress.

There was very very little crying. A few annoyed harrumphs and naww!s, a little whimpering, not much else.
Mothering without breastfeeding.
The breakthrough came at playgroup one Monday morning, when I was just so exhausted and so angry at this gorgeous little two year old in my lap, so annoyed at the fact he still needed to touch me when all I desperately wanted was for nobody to be within a two metre radius of me. I just cried and cried to my beautiful friends there, and that was the first time I said it: I didn't want to breastfeed him any more.

It was like a floodgate of language opened up for me -- I was now able to talk. I could speak to my little one about it, about how it was ouchie for me now (I figured 'ouchie' is a good way to describe my feelings, both physically and mentally) and that I didn't want to any more. I told him that he could have boobie in bed for sleepy-time, but that there was no more boobie in the night time, until the sun came up. I wasn't quite ready to fully wean yet, and thought that I might be totally fine continuing like that for as long as we chose. I didn't once tell him that he was a 'big boy', or 'not a baby anymore', or try anything deceptive, like the stories I have heard of telling them that ants will crawl out of my breasts now if he sucks (eek!), or putting vinegar or chilli on my breasts... I was just honest, and I actually feel really proud of that, and of him for accepting it.

My four year old was always listening, and I realised at some point that I was also teaching him about bodily consent. We have a saying in our house that 'you are the boss of your own body', and I heard him one afternoon telling his little brother that, "Mummy's boobies are Mummy's, and she is the boss of her boobies, and now she likes doing big cuddles in the night the best, instead of boobie." My little one just agreed and went on playing.
These two little loves of mine, always 'having a conversation' :)
So here is how we did it. My thoughts were that it was all about finding replacements -- not taking things away, but replacing them.

  1. Firstly, I made the decision. Fully. No going back, this was it. If he was sick, if we were on holiday, whatever happened, I was making this decision and sticking with it (except when I didn't... more on that later :) ).
  2. I gave him a few days to get used to the idea. I told him that on Friday we would have no more boobie in the night, and only sleepy-time boobie. No more night-time-boobie, and that if he woke in the night he could have his sippy-cup (I had to go and buy two!) and we would snuggle. I realise this idea of time is too complex, really, but this was largely also for my benefit. I do felt that it helped to have a few days for him to get used to the idea. 
  3. I bought my eldest boy a new night-light and took his night/day clock (we have a Kidsleep Clock, which has worked awesomely for us for years now!) so that I would also have the option of feeding him when the sun came up on the clock. 
  4. The big night came, and we talked all afternoon about it. At bed time, we talked about how this was sleepy-time boobie, and if he woke up again then we would snuggle and have sippy-cup, but no more boobie until the sun came up. I talked with him about it during that feed too, and he fed to sleep. 
  5. He woke in the night (surprise! Not.) and I had two sippy cups ready to go -- one with water and one with milk. I figured we could try the water, but had the milk as a back-up. I climbed into his bed, but put my arm firmly down by my side and told him that we can have a big snuggle now, and here is his sippy cup. He didn't want the sippy cup, did one big protest of a simple teenage-style, 'TSK! NAWW!', pushed his body hard up against my bare arm and went back to sleep. WHAAT?!  I know. 
  6.  He woke two more times that night and we repeated. The last time he did take the sippy cup with milk, whimpered a little, and then snuggled in again. 
  7. When the sun came up on the clock, he breastfed, but only for about one minute instead of his usual 20minute hang-out, then wanted to get up and play. 

This repeated almost exactly for two nights, with no major dramas. On the third night, he did get very distressed at one point and I broke all my rules (which is my perogative, right?! Ha) and breastfed him back to sleep. In the morning, we talked about it, and I repeated all the talking we had done before. That was the last time I breastfed him in the night.

What night weaning looks like :D 
The nights from then on became much better for me. I was sure he was still going to wake continually through the night, but his sleep actually did really improve. He would occasionally sleep through, which was unheard of before, but would usually still wake two or three times -- an improvement on six or more! I still went into him without fail, he snuggled against my arm, or sometimes flopped his body all over mine, but it was better. I was feeling better.

After a week, he wasn't interested in breastfeeding in the morning whatsoever, which surprised me, and I must admit it was kind of a pain to suddenly have to get up and be active, rather than have that quiet snooze time to slowly wake. But that's the price we pay, right?

2 years and 5 months
That was in January. We went on like this for four months with no dramas, and then when he was 2 years and 6 months, I decided to take the steps to fully wean... which I'll talk about in my next blog post ;)

** Edit: I have received some thoughtful feedback, and I agree that somewhere in here I should point out that the reason why I feel this worked so well for us is due to his age. He was an early and furious teether, and had ALL his teeth by two years of age, and I can't imagine attempting to gently night-wean while there were still teeth waiting to come through (though some children also seem more affected by this than others). Also, obviously, there are major cognitive differences between a child who is 15 or 17 months and a child who is 28 months, and I could see that he was becoming more independent and confident (though still very quiet, sensitive and needing my physical closeness) and had become an amazing communicator. The logic and reasoning skills that exist at this age played a major role in our sucess, I feel. 

Interview with Me: My Fight with Low Supply

It's time to tell my own story. My story is hard for me to tell, but I feel it is important. I have made many decisions throughout our breastfeeding journey, and all of these things have worked together to ensure that I managed to breastfeed him up until 12 months, then to 24 months, and now still at 29 months. So here is my story, with all the foot stomping, all the tears, all the hallelujahs. This is how I got to where I am:

The Beginning: Dealing with the Past
My second beautiful baby was born at the end of 2014. The months leading up to his birth were filled with anxiety, panic and dread at the thought of having to somehow navigate my way through those first three months again, now also with a highly sensitive toddler at my feet, as those months with my first baby were undoubtedly the hardest of my life. I'd had unexplained low supply with my first little boy, despite over forty lactation consultant appointments all over the country, and I had never found any answers or solutions. I spent much of my second pregnancy working with two lactation consultants, a counsellor and midwife, to accept that this was a different baby and that we should take our breastfeeding relationship on a day-by-day, hour-by-hour basis. After dealing with a lot of past wounds, we managed to be able to bring my baby to my breast after birth, but always maintained my goal of simply not having a hungry baby.

When my second little boy was first put to my breast, I was astonished at how entirely natural it felt. There was no anxiety, no worry, just awe and love. After eight days in hospital, my baby was at my breast for 18-22 hours each day and his weight was stable, but he wasn't gaining. We were discharged and my midwife / lactation consultant came to our house every day for two weeks, and then every second day for the following two weeks. My boy continued to only maintain his weight and his stools remained tar-like meconium – not the mustard-yellow that I so longed for. At ten days, she told me that I needed to supplement. She mentioned a Supplemental Nursing Systems (SNS), and my husband had one shipped express directly from Medela.

Learning to use a Supplemental Nursing System

The 48 hours that it took for the SNS to arrive were some of the longest of my life. For those evenings, my midwife came to my house for three hours, when my supply was at its lowest, and would syringe in some formula supplement while by baby fed at my breast. She taught my husband how to do this and there was one heartbreaking attempt in the early morning hours where everything went wrong: I was in a lot of pain, my husband was getting frustrated that he couldn't do it as easily as my midwife could, my baby cried continually and then vomited up all the milk we worked so hard to get into him... It was then that I looked at those bottles in the back of the bottom drawer and knew how easy it would be to change the course of things right there and then. I realised that I was in the exact same place that I was with my first baby, where I was so blindly adamant to make this work, and I was allowing my baby to be hungry, which I had vowed I would not do. I cried to my husband as he walked around the house with our baby in the carrier, I cried in the toilet, I had a bath, I cried some more, I apologised profusely to my little baby, I went into my big boy's room to kiss him while he slept, and I didn't give a bottle. I have since learnt that the nights are not times to make big decisions – everything seems better in the day. The SNS came the next morning. I know that this was the right decision for me, and I was lucky that my baby fed well with the SNS. I am aware, however, that I held a deep paranoia that the moment my baby has milk from any other source besides my breast, he will refuse to breastfeed any longer. I logically know that this is not true, I know that absolutely not all babies are like this, and yet it is a deep and intense feeling inside me that I must never give him a bottle. This of course resulted in him being one hundred percent reliant on me for his milk, but this was a choice that I continued to make every day, every feed.

And so, for five and a half months, I fed my boy with a Supplemental Nursing System. When I first began using this, I was entirely housebound, which felt incredibly unfair to my two-and-a-half year old... I was petrified that anyone seeing me use this system would judge me, see me as less than the perfect mother to my children – both the baby I was unable to exclusively feed, and the toddler I was unable to give my full attention to. I was also afraid that people might presume, when seeing the presence of these tubes, that my baby is sick, and the thought of that filled me with panic. Living as an immigrant in a country where the language barrier remains a daily battle (an Australian in Switzerland) just exacerbated these issues, as any attention from any member of the public caused me anxiety as I might be unable to express myself in the way that I really wanted to. I began to realise that nobody in Switzerland seemed to really know about it, not the paediatrician, and not even the nurses at the children's hospital when we had to visit one night. The lactation consultants I spoke to knew of it only to induce lactation for adoptive mothers, or for mothers who had had mastectomies. I slowly began to feel a sense of pride and to see it as my duty to introduce this contraption to the world as simply another way that women can feed their babies. I would feed in public, with the bottle and tubes on full display, and actually hope that people would look and ask questions. This was the beginning of my desire to share my knowledge, and I know that I have helped a number of women by simply allowing them to see this system in action.

I began to experience glimpses of the joys of a breastfeeding relationship. I could bring my baby to my breast when he was unsettled or in pain, and he would find calm there. I could feed him to sleep and feed him to awake, and when he was four months old, I began to be able to feed him throughout the night without any supplement, which was life-changing. Although I had successfully established this relationship, I was not satisfied. I could not understand why I was unable to breastfeed, and instead of having moments, hours and days where I would feel very sad and depressed, I began to feel very angry. All the expert consultations I received concluded the same way: I had done everything humanly possible, I was to be congratulated and I should enjoy this relationship. But I wasn't satisfied: I wanted to be enough for him, and I wasn't, and nobody could tell me why. I focused on eating and drinking to promote lactation (do you know how many 'tips' there are globally?!), including the use of herbs, homeopathics, vitamins and, eventually with the medication domperidone (Motillium). A tongue and lip tie had been ruled out at birth and a few weeks later, as had hormonal imbalances, placental remnants and lack of breast tissue. I came to the conclusion that it must simply be my personality that were the cause of my low supply: My thought processes, my overanalysis, my intensity. This was hard. Really hard. I would look at my boy's beautiful chubby feet and instead of feeling proud that I am feeding him the amount his body needs, I would wonder how much of that is from my milk, and how much is from supplement -- both donor milk, and formula. His big toe – is that the supplement toe? I realised the total lack of rationality of these feelings, and yet... I couldn't accept it. I've never been good at accepting help, from people or from milk.

Choosing to Medicate

Choosing to use domperidone (brand name Motillium) was also a very important step in our journey. Switzerland seems to be the home of all things anthroposophic and homeopathic; I chose a small, alternative, anthroposophic hospital to birth my children and I chose the most 'alternative' midwife I could find, as I felt the most deeply connected to her. It was after a lot of intense introspection, a lot of questioning and speculation, that I decided to speak with her about domperidone usage. I was relieved that she was so open to the idea and was entirely supportive of trying it, but she admitted to me that she did not know very much at all about it, and once again it is a very uncommon here in Switzerland. Indeed, when I wrote to the past lactation consultants that I had used for my first baby, none of them had any experience using it either. I managed to get a prescription to take 60mg for eight days and see if the amount of supplement required reduced. This meant that, for the first time, I had to track the number of times I was feeding him and the amount of supplement he was taking. I had avoided doing this beforehand, as I had worked with my lactation consultant/counsellor to allow my mind to be in a place that did not overanalyse such things.

I began to do my own very intense research into domperidone usage and realised quickly that this prescription I received was potentially not going to do much at all. I had a Skype consultation with an Australian lactation consultant who reinforced my ideas and encouraged me to try a higher dose, and I was in correspondence with Dr Jack Newman who also encouraged a higher dosage for a longer period of time. After two days, I called my midwife armed with literally dozens of scientific articles and anecdotal reports that demonstrated that I needed a higher dosage for a much longer period of time. She laughed, told me that in the past week I had probably become Switzerland's expert in domperidone usage, and immediately sent me an open-ended prescription to take as much as needed for as long as needed. Supplementation went down from 50% of his probable daily intake to around 15-20%. After six months, I began to slowly wean one tablet per week. Occasionally my milk supply would drop drastically and I would go back up again. It took around four months for me to be able to wean off domperidone completely. Domperidone was not necessary in ensuring that my baby did not go hungry, as per my original goal, but it was one step closer to achieving my dream of being able to feed my boy with no supplemental milk.

A Diagnosis
At five months, I stopped mentioning to anybody about how I longed to exclusively breastfeed my little boy, because I just became so tired of justifying the claim of having not enough milk, of rattling off the dozens upon dozens of supplements and tricks that, yes, we had tried. The claim of not having enough milk is so common now, and its ubiquity seemed, irrationally, to lessen the justification of my pain. I want to be part of the Exclusive Breastfeeders Club like nothing I have wanted before, and instead I belonged to the Low Milk Supply Club, or even worse, the Claims She Has Low Milk Supply Club (but-she-is-yet-to-treat-the-underlying-cause). In a fit of rage at the latest expert who did nothing but congratulate me, I posted a photo on my breastfeeding blog of my boy's tongue. When comment after comment came in from friends who said that it did, indeed, look like a tongue tie – as I had claimed six months before – I felt as if my world was imploding. I could not find any reason or logic in anything that I was doing anymore and became a confused, anxious wreck. All that I knew that was true was being turned on its head. The potential idea that my inability to feed my two children was actually nothing to do with my body and my breasts, and may actually be due to them and their anatomy, sent me reeling. This was indeed confirmed by the paediatric dentist, who, meanwhile, was the first person to congratulate me on continually searching for answers.

The photo that got everyone talking.

My baby was almost six months old when I managed to snag that appointment with the paediatric dentist for his tongue tie, while we were holidaying in Australia. On our way there, I was very conflicted, I was deeply unsure of what I would want to do if they found a problem; all I knew was that I wanted answers. He has just recently started solids once a day, so I was thinking that maybe it wasn't even necessary. I questioned whether I was just being selfish now, wanting to breastfeed him when it perhaps wasn't so vital for him anymore, and did I really want him to have a surgical procedure and to endure pain in order for us to do that? I felt that I just needed to know, then I could make my decisions later. When the dentist confirmed tongue and lip ties, we discussed options: If this was a five week old baby, he said, he wouldn't hesitate; It would make an enormous difference to feeding. But now, my little one has learnt how to feed in his own way, and it would perhaps not change anything. But I had my answers. He discussed the fact that this procedure is purely a 'first world procedure', as he called it, stating that if nothing is done, my baby would continue to thrive and grow up happy and healthy. He then told me he could remove the tongue-tie right then with a laser, in a one minute painless procedure (using anaesthetic cream), but whether that would make a significant difference or not is unknown, and he would really only do it in cases where the mother was incredibly passionate about breastfeeding. I assured him that this, indeed, was me, and upon further discussion I was convinced of the true painless nature of the procedure. I made my choice: I had to try. If I didn't I would always wonder, and it was important to me to try not to have any regrets along this journey. This is a choice that I have not for one second regretted. It was through this choice, I believe, that I managed to achieve my dream of being able to breastfeed supplement-free.

After his posterior tongue-tie was lasered, I nursed him for a long time, and then we just sat together in the silence. I was searching for my reaction, but I had none. I knew that it would be logical to be angry at all those experts who told me that he didn't have a tongue tie; to perhaps feel elated that I may have found the real answer to this riddle; to celebrate what may be the next step that I had so longed for. But I just felt empty. Deep deep emptiness. It was after a lot of crying and a lot of time alone in the week that followed that I realised how deeply I still mourned the loss of the breastfeeding relationship with my first beautiful boy. I was, quite simply, sad. He is an extremely sensitive child, a little boy who cries when any song in a minor key is played; a little boy who runs to me panic stricken whenever he can hear another child upset; a little boy who rubs my cheek with his little hands and tells me he is happy and that he loves me infinite; a little boy who so easily becomes overwhelmed in this great big world around him. He is a little boy who would have so benefited from the connectedness and the comfort that breastfeeding brings, but I had found out the answers too late for him.

What I learnt – About my personality, my body and my instincts
I have learnt that I hold onto things. I cling onto my pain and I must resolve to 'let it go' more often in all aspects of my life. I had never before truly realised the extent of my stubbornness. Sure, my husband has mentioned it on occasion before, when it rears its ugly head from time to time, but I have learnt that if there is anything in my life that I truly set my heart on, I will be willing to go through anything to achieve my goal. Being this way is both a blessing and a curse, as I am sure that this trait of mine is largely responsible for sticking with the SNS for so long, for continuing to hunt for answers. I have learnt the degree of self-sacrifice that I will put myself through for my children knows no bounds, but that this is also not necessarily a good thing, and that I also need to focus on self-love and healing. I do know, though, that no matter what decisions I made during the first year of my second-baby's life, it would have been a very difficult year for me.

I have come a long way in dealing with my body issues regarding to breastfeeding. I spent years believing that my body is flawed, of hating my breasts and their total futility, of struggling to come to terms with being unable to fulfil that primitive need to keep my baby alive with my body alone. When I stopped attempting to breastfeed my first baby, I literally wanted to chop off both of my breasts. Literally. I saw them as entirely non-functional and they became a symbol of failure that were permanently attached to my body. They were the source of so much pain, and each time I looked at them I was reminded of my grief and of all that I could not do for my baby. This time around, my breastfeeding journey has been intense not only due to the breastfeeding itself, but because it has also been a journey of learning to love myself. My midwife noted the way that I prodded at my breasts, poked them, treated them roughly and with no love whatsoever. She helped me to discover a new frame of thinking, taught me to be gentle with myself, physically as well as mentally. I have come a long way in accepting that while my body is flawed, it is to be loved and respected. I was incredibly lucky to have two relatively trouble-free pregnancies and two incredible births, which is one of the body's greatest tests, and something that I must always love my body for being capable of achieving.

Another interesting thing that I have learnt along my journey is that breastfeeding to me is absolutely not about the milk itself. It is not about the massive nutritional benefits it provides for my child and all of the many other benefits that are readily discussed; it is about my instinct to be a breastfeeding mother. If my boy were to have never successfully latched, I have come to realise that I would not have been one of those incredible mothers who pumps exclusively for my child so that he can consume my milk from a bottle. I'd like to think that I would have, but I know deep down that this is not the case. When I had the opportunity to use donormilk, I took it and loved the knowledge that he was getting one-hundred-percent breastmilk, but it didn't fill me with the intense satisfaction that so many around me had expected. I wanted to bring my child to my breast in his time of need, whatever need that may be, and for him to find solace, satisfaction and everything that he requires. It is only once we managed to remove the need for any supplemental milk that I was capable of doing this, and it was then that I had achieved my dream. Only then did my breasts serve not only as the provider of milk, but also of all of those other things I desired: as pain relief, as a way to find calm when the world is overwhelming, as a way to drift slowly to sleep, as a way to relieve hiccups, as a way to relieve frustration, and simply as snuggles and comfort.

My journey is exactly that – it is mine. I made many choices along the way, every single day. I empowered myself with information, with scientific, esoteric knowledge, and I never stopped (and I think will never stop!) my quest to continue to learn. I do not wish for any mother's journey to follow the path that mine did, but I wish for information to be made readily available to them, for them to be able to actively make informed decisions. This is what all mothers need to be able to move into motherhood with confidence, along with wonderful, knowledgeable support networks, and this is my goal in assisting new mamas. And perhaps one day I actually will get a tattoo: I have enough, I do enough, I am enough.

Breastfeeding Aversion, or 'Wanting to Scream, Run and Break Things'

I thought  breastfeeding aversion, or nursing aversion and agitation, was something that only inflicted pregnant mothers. And I'm not pregnant, so why have I had so many moments of hating breastfeeding lately?

My little boy is over two years old now. Considering I was unsure I'd be able to breastfeed him even once, this blows my mind. Two years kind of slipped by unassumingly, actually. I no longer felt that breastfeeding was an active choice I was making, but had simply become a very personal part of my mothering. He stopped breastfeeding in the day at around 18 months, and always adamantly declared 'Nei!' when I offered. Nights, though, have always been a different story. The various pros and cons are changing, and my own breastfeeding experience is continuing to challenge and educate me... and nursing aversion is a big part of that.

For the past 9-ish months, there is usually two evenings every month where I put my toddler to bed in our usual manner -- singing the Long Time Sun Song, lying down together in his big double bed, turning on his sleepy music (Bon Iver -- he has good taste) and breastfeeding him either to sleep or to almost sleep. Nothing is different to the norm, and yet these two or sometimes three evenings a month, I emerge in tears, seething with such intense rage, wanting to scream and throw something that will break into a hundred pieces, after trying so hard not to hurt my little boy for the time that he was nursing, and wishing I could just run out the door and just keep run run running to a dark cave where nobody will touch me for the next year.

Jetlag: Too tired for PJs, too tired even for boobie!
It turns out, this feeling has a name. Nursing Aversion. Or sometimes Breastfeeding Agitation. I had ruled this out, as I wasn't pregnant... but when I went into my chat history of when I wrote in floods of tears to my two best breastfeeding support buddies, each episode was exactly in time with my cycle, in the days before my period and for usually one day during ovulation. It seems that, yes, it is hormonal. Geez, hormones have a lot to answer for. Also, often at these times, my milk supply is very low, almost non-existent, so his feeds are longer and more frequent at exactly the time when I hate it.

So I found myself sitting on the couch with my husband who steeled himself and dared to ask me if I wanted to wean. He held me as I sobbed and said yes, but I don't know how. I mean, yes, I know all the practical 'hows', but the emotional? No idea.

The next day? Weaning wasn't even on the table. I enjoyed it again, enjoyed being there for my boy to comfort him and be what he needs in the night. I dreamt of him night-weaning, but also feared that this would be the end, as he didn't feed in the day (read about how I managed to gently night-wean later here). The few times I have gotten my husband to help out in the nights (he always deals with our eldest at night, who sleeps through almost consistently, finally!), it has almost always been a disaster and been more emotional trauma than it was worth, so we just continue to plod along.
Airport breastfeeding, at what would have been 10.30pm. 
Now that I know this is true nursing aversion, though, it helps. Having labels for things helps. Being able to share stories with other mothers who have been there helps. We all get strength from one another in this motherhood tribe. Weaning is definitely on the cards, at least partially, and me learning to set boundaries when it comes to breastfeeding has been incredibly hard. I am, though, and I am learning more and more about how to look after myself too. To have worked so hard for so long to get here, and then to find myself in this situation, is sometimes... well, it is complicated.

But I'm not one to keep things simple ;)

Interview with Claire: Constant Pain

Claire is a Switzerland-based Australian writer whose passionate, thought-provoking musings and poetry can be found at clairevetica.wordpress.com. The clarity and intensity in both her self and her writing is something that I have long admired. Claire's first child was born in London and her second child in Zurich.

What were your thoughts and expectations about breastfeeding before you gave birth? 

I didn’t really think much about breastfeeding before I had kids. While pregnant with my first child in London in 2010-2011, like most women in my position, I was mostly focused on the pregnancy and the impending, terrifying Major Life Event of actually giving birth. It seemed as though the books I was reading and the people I spoke to focused on that too, rather than talking much about what came afterwards. Or maybe I just wasn’t paying attention.

I guess the thoughts I did have about breastfeeding were that it seemed vaguely ick to me personally (ie: while I’m not grossed out by others doing it AT ALL, I didn’t love the thought of doing it myself). I don’t think I’d heard of people having major problems with breastfeeding, apart from mastitis, (which sounded bad enough – but as though most people got through it and went on to bf fine). However, breastfeeding seemed like the Right Thing To Do and if women had been doing this for millennia, why wouldn’t I? I guess I felt much the same about giving birth “naturally” (ie: vaginally, without drugs) – again something that women had been doing since the dawn of time. The natural birth went fine. The breastfeeding did not.

How were those first few days and weeks? Did you feel supported? 

Speaking at the WHO

Last weekend, I travelled to Geneva to speak on a panel at the World Health Organisation's Baby Friendly Hospital Initiative congress. Surrounded by over 300 experts from 137 countries, I shared my story and apparently made a whole bunch of them cry (including myself). 

I am still in disbelief that I can open a blog post with that. Isn't it entirely mind-boggling?! Being able to do this is an absolute dream come true, and absolutely one that I had never envisioned happening -- at least not for the next forty years, anyway. I have never before felt so humbled, such a small fish in a big pond, so incredibly in awe of the power and influence that this group of passionate people held over a subject that is so dear to my heart. It was in my preparation that I truly realised the gravity of what I had been asked to do: 'So you are here, surrounded by the most influential and knowledgeable people in this field, from all corners of the globe. What is it that you think they should be doing differently? What do you want them to do to change the experiences of women in the next generation?' 

Interview with Rachel: "I didn't really breastfeed"

Rachel, an American mother living in Switzerland, writes the inspiring expat lifestyle blog My Mini AdventurerI asked Rachel to be a part of Milk and Motherhood after meeting for coffee and learning that she, in her own words, 'didn't really breastfeed'. 

This beautiful, dedicated mother breastfed her little baby for three months before too many obstacles and difficulties led her to the realisation that continuing was not the best decision for her family. I feel very honoured that she agreed to share her story with me here. 

Did you go into motherhood with a firm idea of how you wanted to feed your baby?

It was doomed from the start, really. The moment they took my little guy away and whisked him off to the NICU, we didn’t stand a chance. I just didn’t know it at the time.

Your friend has low supply?

As someone who has struggled with low supply for both of my babies, who had over forty appointments with lactation consultants throughout Switzerland and also in Australia, who used formula and donor milk through a Supplemental Nursing System for almost six months, who tried seemingly every milk-building remedy from every culture on earth, it's time I write this post.

I had some truly wonderful friends during this time, but I also lost friends during this time, which still breaks my heart.

The first few beads sent to me by friends and family around the world for strength and love during the birth and postnatal period. My most valuable possession. There is so much love right there.
If you find yourself sitting next to your friend who is struggling with low supply, whether you consider it true low supply or merely 'perceived low supply', here's a few tips.

Disclaimer: I am a very sensitive person. During the first six months of each of my baby's lives, I was the most vulnerable and emotionally pained that I have ever been. All I can do is share my own personal experience.


1. 'Do you really have low supply?' This is hard. There is a lot of information out there about how to ensure you truly do have low supply, and that your fussing baby, empty-feeling breasts and bottle-guzzler don't necessarily mean you aren't producing enough milk. But you are her friend, not her lactation consultant. Don't question her, don't expect her to explain to you in detail about all the ways she is (or feels she is) unable to provide for her baby. Don't get her to justify her pain to you.

2. 'Have you tried fennel tea?' or any number of remedies... lactation cookies, beer, more skin to skin, checking for tongue tie, staying in bed for a weekend with baby, meditation, domperidone, etc. Again, unless she specifically asks you for advice, don't offer it. Chances are you are the ten-thousandth person that has mentioned this to her, and you might just be the straw that breaks the camel's back and have a box of breastfeeding tea thrown in your face.

Back to Top